Compound with René

Compound with René

Market Commentary

Buy Good Companies, Don't Overpay, Do EVERYTHING ...

Terry Smith spent fifteen years telling us to do nothing. His latest letter does the opposite.

René Sellmann's avatar
René Sellmann
Jul 08, 2026

“I think people who study the psychology of investment will tell you that, you know, you can't have an end to certain types of market until the last hope is given up. I mean, I presume after that the entire UBS funds were switched into something which tracked the the Nasdaq index, bought all those things. And oh dear, there we are.“ - Terry Smith at this year’s Fundsmith AGM

Let me say something up front, before I say anything critical. I’ve learned an enormous amount from Terry Smith over the years. His quality-first principles, laid out in plain language that any investor could absorb, shaped how I think about businesses.

The rational temperament, the refusal to be dragged around by the crowd, the insistence that you focus on what a company actually does rather than what its share price did last week – that’s been an inspiration to me and to a whole generation of retail investors who found a way into serious investing partly through his letters and the recorded AGMs that were then uploaded on YouTube.

Earlier this year, when the pile-on over his underperformance was at its loudest, I was one of the people defending him. I watched this year’s AGM and came away thinking his reasoning was still clear, still rational, still willing to question the lazy conclusions you reach when you let herd instinct do your thinking for you.

Then I read the July letter yesterday evening. And I was, frankly, in shock.

Because it reads like a man throwing that rational thinking overboard.

A note on the spirit of this

One more thing before I get into it. I try to follow Buffett’s principle: praise by name, criticise by category.

I’m not going to manage that here. This post names names, and the name is Terry Smith. And in some weird way I feel bad about it, and will hit the release button regardless.

So let me be clear about the spirit in which it’s written. I mean it with the best of intentions – as food for thought, and if anyone at Fundsmith happens to read it, so much the better.

There’s also a simple reality that comes with the territory. When you manage billions – with a B – of other people’s money, you accept a degree of public scrutiny of your decisions. It comes with the chair.

There’s a line from the former German Chancellor Helmut Kohl I was thinking of in this regard. Faced with sharp press criticism, mockery, and political hostility over the course of his time in office, he expressed a version of the same idea again and again. Anyone who reaches for the highest office in a democracy has no business complaining afterwards about the harsh headwinds. You take the job, you take the weather.

My German readers can watch a clip in which he states exactly this here:

To this day the line gets thrown back at his successors (as in the clip above) whenever they grumble about the tone of the media.

And I think it applies, in its own way, to anyone managing billions of other people’s capital, too. Nobody forced the job on you.

Full Tilt

In poker there’s a concept called tilt. I played a lot of online poker in my younger days – my favourite platform, fittingly, was called Full Tilt.

Tilt is what happens when a good player stops playing his game. He takes a bad beat, or a run of them, and the frustration takes over. He starts chasing. He plays hands he’d normally fold. He abandons the discipline that made him a winning player in the first place, precisely because it stopped working for a stretch, and he convinces himself that the answer is to do more, do it faster, and force a result.

The tragic thing about tilt is that it feels like decisiveness from the inside. It looks like activity. It’s actually the absence of the thing that made you good.

I think Terry Smith might have just gone full tilt.

His whole credo, the thing printed on the tin, was three lines. Buy good companies. Don’t overpay. Do nothing. He shared this credo in his latest letter again.

And yet, as outlined in the letter, now he is doing an awful lot.

I count twelve buys and thirteen exits in a single half-year.

In his own words: “our portfolio turnover hit a high of 51% in the first half of this year.”

For a manager whose full-year 2025 turnover was 12.7%, that is … quite something.

It is the buy-and-hold monk at the poker table suddenly playing every hand at the table.

I tweeted yesterday that if someone had shown me the paragraphs laying out all these transactions back in April, I genuinely could not have told you whether it was an April Fool’s joke. And I mean genuinely.

Twenty-five major portfolio decisions in roughly six months? AppLovin, Uber, Netflix, TSMC, GE Vernova, Mastercard, Yum!, TJX, on the buy side. Novo Nordisk, Unilever, LVMH, Nike, Zoetis, Coloplast, Intuit, on the way out. This is anything but the Terry Smith we thought we knew.

So here’s the question I keep turning over. What stage of the market cycle is it when a die-hard quality investor – someone who has practised this exact discipline for decades – reinvents himself as a momentum trader?

“We will take more account of momentum — both fundamental and share price — in our investment decisions.“

I’ve always been a bit of a skeptic on the prices he paid, and I’ll come back to that. But the man’s identity was patience. This was his edge. When that breaks, it tells you something. Usually not about the companies. About the pressure. It’s on.

He sees the problem clearly. That’s what makes this so strange.

The frustrating part is that Smith’s diagnosis of the market is largely right, and beautifully argued. The letter’s first half is vintage Terry.

He lays out how a market now dominated by passive flows and the AI capex boom has become a momentum machine, one that no longer prices businesses on “profitability, returns on capital and growth – in other words the factors we focus on.”

He leans on Simon Evan-Cook’s excellent “Victory for Passive!” piece. He quotes David Booth, of all people, admitting that “index funds are really trading desks.” He points out that active managers, though still 40% of assets, are down to something like 10% of actual trading volume, so the marginal price is set almost entirely by the flow machine. He shows the Bloomberg momentum chart sitting at a thirty-year high, more stretched than late 1999.

Momentum Is Showing Record Outperformance – “It is at a 30 year high and more extreme than in late 1999 just before the Dotcom bubble burst. As active fund performance continues to worsen, more people abandon it, producing a pernicious feedback loop.”

I agree with almost all of this. In fact, the most valuable thing I’ve published on this blog in recent months, I believe, isn’t any single deep dive. It’s my three-part perception-change framework, which is about exactly this: how to you improve your timing skills in a perception-driven market?

I’d encourage Smith to read it. If he messages me, I’ll gift him a lifetime subscription, no charge, of course. Again, I write all of this with good intentions. He seems to be an avid Substack reader as he even references a blog post he read on this platform early in the letter.

Process

Playing a Different Game: When Fundamentals Aren’t Enough Anymore! (Part 1)

René Sellmann
·
Jan 10
Playing a Different Game: When Fundamentals Aren’t Enough Anymore! (Part 1)

This will be a 3-part series. If you don’t want to miss the follow-up pieces, make sure to subscribe to the blog.

Read full story

But here’s the thing that stops me cold. Having diagnosed a momentum bubble, having said in plain type that he has “no insight into how or when this passive-led momentum market will end, other than to say badly” – he then responds by leaning into momentum?

He tells us he will “take more account of momentum – both fundamental and share price – in our investment decisions.”

You’ve just described a casino where the roulette wheel is rigged and the last table of value players is being carried out on stretchers. And your conclusion is to pull up a chair and start betting on red because red’s been hot?

That’s the tilt. He sees the trap with total clarity and walks into it anyway, because standing still has become unbearable.

Leave a comment

Learning from Druckenmiller

There’s a story every investor should have tattooed somewhere. In early 2000, Stanley Druckenmiller, one of the greatest to ever do it, walked into George Soros’s office and said he was selling all the tech stocks. This is crazy at 104 times earnings, he said. This is nuts.

He had it exactly right. And then he had to sit there and watch two young gunslingers inside the same firm make 3% a day, their little account up 50% on the year while Quantum sat flat. It drove him mad.

In his own telling: “So like around March I could feel it coming. I just – I had to play. I couldn’t help myself. And three times during the same week I pick up a phone, don’t do it. Don’t do it. Anyway, I pick up the phone finally. I think I missed the top by an hour. I bought $6 billion worth of tech stocks and in six weeks I had left Soros and I had lost $3 billion in that one play.”

Then the part that should stop any investor cold. Asked what he learned: “I didn’t learn anything. I already knew that I wasn’t supposed to do that. I was just an emotional basket case and couldn’t help myself.”

Read that and then read Smith’s letter again. Druckenmiller didn’t lose three billion because he misjudged the businesses.

He lost it because he couldn’t bear being cold while everyone around him was hot.

The diagnosis was right and the discipline broke anyway, precisely at the moment of maximum envy, precisely at the top.

That’s the same machinery I see running in this letter. Smith has the correct read on the bubble in the very same pages where he decides to start chasing it. He’s chasing. Full stop. I think that’s what’s really happening here. And that’s rarely a good long-term strategy.

And here’s the lesson Druckenmiller has spent the years since preaching, the one that matters most for Smith right now: when you’re not hot, you take a break.

You reduce size, you step back, you wait for a pitch you can actually hit. What you do not do is tear up the entire strategy, the entire identity you’ve built as an investor, because a cold streak has become psychologically intolerable.

Cold streaks are not a signal to become a different person. They’re a signal to protect the person you already are until the conditions turn back in your favour. That’s also your fiduciary duty, managing other people’s capital.

The consistency problem

The rest of this post is FREE to read. I only ask that you subscribe, which costs nothing and can be undone with a single click whenever you like.

The wall also helps keep my writing from being freely scraped by AI crawlers, so I hope you understand the small extra step.

In return, you get every deep dive, earnings review, and process piece I publish, straight to your inbox.

Subscribe for free to continue reading

Enter your email and get every post from Compound with René.
Already have an account? Sign in
© 2026 René Sellmann · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.