Compound with René

Compound with René

Process

Thinking in Bets: What Poker and Horse Racing Teach Us About Markets

Three Worlds, One Core Idea!

René Sellmann's avatar
René Sellmann
Apr 25, 2025

Most people wouldn’t naturally group stock market investing, poker, and horse betting into the same category. One has billion-dollar companies and earnings calls, another is played in smoke-filled card rooms (or sleek online interfaces), and the third involves animals, turf, and betting slips.

But peel back the surface layers, and you’ll find that all three domains are deeply connected by one powerful thread: they’re probabilistic disciplines.

What does that mean? It means that success in any of them doesn’t come from always being right, but from consistently making high-quality decisions in the face of uncertainty, incomplete information, and randomness. The outcomes are noisy.

Skill plays a role, yes—but so does luck. And while luck may dominate the short term, process-driven thinking and sound probabilistic reasoning win out over time.

This is a mindset shift that many investors – especially newer ones – struggle to make. We’re wired to crave certainty, to seek patterns, to believe that good outcomes come from good decisions and bad outcomes from bad ones. But in probabilistic environments, that just isn’t how it works.

You can make a perfect decision and still lose money.

You can make a terrible call and get lucky. And the reverse.

That’s why I find it so valuable to study other domains where this probabilistic nature is front and center, especially poker and horse betting. Both force participants to constantly weigh odds, assess ranges, understand risk and reward, and – crucially – manage variance.

And if you can train your brain to think probabilistically in those arenas, you’ll be far better prepared to navigate the messy, complex world of investing.

In this post, I want to explore what poker, horse betting, and investing have in common, and just as importantly, where they diverge.

I’ll look at how luck, skill, and competition intersect, why sample size matters more than we think, how process over outcome is the only sane way to think long-term, and why investing is perhaps less like poker than many believe, and more like betting on horses; at least if you’re doing it thoughtfully.

This is a deep dive, so we’re going to explore:

  • Why variance can obscure even the best decisions

  • How luck vs. skill plays out differently in each field

  • Why competition changes the landscape over time

  • How poker’s concept of +EV decisions maps to investing

  • Why risk and uncertainty aren’t the same and why it matters

  • And finally, why horse betting may offer the richest analogy for investors

Whether you're just getting started in investing or you've been at it for years, understanding how probabilistic thinkers in other fields manage decisions, edge, and emotion can dramatically sharpen your own process.

Thanks for reading Quality Investing with René Sellmann! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Part I: The Nature of Probabilistic Disciplines

At the core of investing, poker, and horse betting lies one uncomfortable truth: you can do everything right and still lose.

That’s because these are probabilistic disciplines, not deterministic ones.

The outcomes – at least over smaller sample sizes – aren’t guaranteed, no matter how good your decision-making process is. And for many people, especially those new to investing, that’s a hard pill to swallow.

Let’s define what that actually means.

What Makes a Discipline Probabilistic?

In a deterministic world, A leads to B. If I turn the key in my car’s ignition (and nothing’s broken), the engine starts. Every time. No uncertainty, no randomness.

In contrast, probabilistic environments are governed by chance, variability, and incomplete information. You can stack the odds in your favor, but there’s still a roll of the dice.

You make decisions based on what’s likely, not what’s certain.

Here’s how that plays out in our three domains:

  • In investing, you may have a strong thesis about a company’s future cash flows, a solid margin of safety, and a compelling valuation, but the stock still drops because of macro headwinds or a black swan event you couldn’t predict.

  • In poker, you might get all your chips in as a 91% favorite and still lose the pot; because the 9% outcome happens.

  • In horse betting, your analysis might be spot on, but an unexpected stumble at the gate or a brilliant ride from a competitor’s jockey turns your high-probability pick into a second-place finisher.

The implication here is profound: results in the short term are not reliable indicators of skill. You can win with a bad process and lose with a good one. That messiness is part of what makes probabilistic domains so difficult … and so fascinating!

It’s also why many participants in these fields fall into a dangerous trap: outcome bias.

They evaluate decisions based on what happened, rather than what was likely to happen at the time.

In poker, that leads to “tilt.”

In investing, it leads to abandoning a strategy right before it pays off, or doubling down on a lucky win that had no foundation.

The antidote is thinking in expected value.

Thanks for reading Quality Investing with René Sellmann! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Thinking in Expected Value (EV)

In both poker and investing, I try to evaluate decisions through the lens of expected value (EV), not outcome.

EV = (Probability of Outcome A × Payoff of Outcome A) + (Probability of Outcome B × Payoff of Outcome B) + ...

You will never know the exact probabilities in investing the way you do in poker, but the mindset still applies. If you’re making decisions where the expected value is positive, and you repeat those decisions often enough, you’ll come out ahead in the long run.

This is what separates professionals from amateurs in all three fields. Professionals understand that a single outcome doesn’t define the quality of a decision. It’s the underlying process – the logic, the discipline, the reasoning – that determines whether you’re playing a winning game.

Embracing the Noise

The hardest part about probabilistic disciplines is learning to live with the noise. Especially when money is on the line, it’s emotionally painful to watch a good bet go south. It’s tempting to second-guess yourself, abandon your framework, or seek false certainty where none exists.

But here’s the truth: in investing, poker, and horse betting, the goal is not to be right all the time. The goal is to be right enough, often enough, with a large enough edge, over a large enough sample size, to come out ahead.

In other words, you need to think like a statistician, not a fortune teller.

Part II: Understanding Variance and the Role of Sample Size

If you’ve ever lost money on a well-researched investment or had a great poker hand cracked by a miracle river card, you’ve felt the sting of variance.

And if you reacted emotionally – blaming yourself, changing your process, or swearing off the game altogether – you’re not alone.

Variance messes with our heads.

But understanding it is absolutely critical to surviving in probabilistic domains.

What Is Variance, Really?

Variance is the statistical concept that measures the spread between expected outcomes and actual outcomes. In simpler terms: it’s how much “noise” surrounds your signal.

In poker, you might make the same +EV decision a hundred times and see wildly different results each time. You could win 10 times in a row or lose 20 times straight. That’s not a reflection of your skill; it’s just how probability works.

Take the example below: It shows a range of possible outcomes for a poker player who beats the game by 8 big bets over 100 hands and who plays 5,000 hands. His expected value is 400 big bets (8*5,000), but as you can see he will also lose money in various scenarios.

In investing, you can buy high-quality businesses at attractive valuations and still see negative returns for months, or even years, due to market sentiment, macro shocks, sector rotation, or most importantly, the businesses do not develop the way you anticipated (for whatever reason! – e.g. unlikely regulatory changes). Again, not a reflection of your process. Just variance doing what variance does.

Poker’s Hierarchy of Variance

Poker offers a perfect laboratory for studying variance, especially when you compare its different formats:

  • Limit Hold’em: Relatively low variance. Betting is capped, so pots are smaller and the swings more manageable.

  • No-Limit Hold’em: Higher variance. One mistake (or one cooler) can cost your whole stack.

  • Pot-Limit Omaha (PLO): Even higher variance. More starting cards, more drawing potential, and more action mean that even strong hands are rarely more than 60-65% favorites.

PLO players, in particular, understand that their edge plays out over massive sample sizes. You can be an elite player and go on brutal downswings simply because the standard deviation is so high. Consider the same inputs we used before, but we increase the standard deviation from 60 to 160 to account for the variance in PLO. This time, a player who should expect to win 400BBs over 5,000 hands may end up losing 3,000BBs!

That’s why pros often talk about needing hundreds of thousands of hands to confirm an edge.

The rest of this post is FREE to read. I only ask that you subscribe, which costs nothing and can be undone with a single click whenever you like.

The wall also helps keep my writing from being freely scraped by AI crawlers, so I hope you understand the small extra step.

In return, you get every deep dive, earnings review, and process piece I publish, straight to your inbox.

Subscribe for free to continue reading

Enter your email and get every post from Compound with René.
Already have an account? Sign in
© 2026 René Sellmann · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.